Research

The Psychology of Attraction: Why We're Drawn to Certain People

Published on
July 1, 2025
Wayne Fraser, founder of Our 2 Souls
Wayne Fraser
Woman sitting alone by water at golden hour with mystical overlay of numbers and geometric patterns

Table of Contents

There's a moment that feels like magic—when your eyes meet across a crowded room and something invisible but undeniable passes between you. Your heart quickens, your breath catches, and suddenly the world narrows to just this person who was a stranger seconds ago. We call it chemistry, spark, or love at first sight, but beneath this romantic poetry lies an intricate symphony of psychological and biological forces that science is only beginning to understand.

Attraction isn't the random lightning strike we imagine it to be. Research in evolutionary psychology and neuroscience reveals that our hearts and minds follow ancient patterns, responding to subtle cues that signal genetic compatibility, emotional safety, and reproductive potential. Yet this same research shows that attraction is deeply personal, shaped by our individual histories, attachment patterns, and the invisible architecture of our unconscious minds.

What draws you to someone else is both universal and utterly unique—a dance between species-wide patterns and the intimate story of who you've become. Understanding this psychology transforms attraction from mysterious fate to conscious choice, allowing you to recognize why certain people captivate you while others leave you feeling nothing at all. At Our2Souls, we've observed that individuals who understand their attraction patterns make more intentional choices about connection and compatibility, leading to relationships that satisfy both heart and mind.

What Creates That Initial Spark of Attraction?

The moment of attraction involves multiple brain systems activating simultaneously—reward circuits flood with dopamine, attention networks sharpen focus, and attachment systems begin evaluating potential for deeper connection.

The Neuroscience of First Impressions

Within milliseconds of encountering someone new, your brain conducts an elaborate assessment that happens entirely below conscious awareness. The visual cortex processes facial symmetry, the limbic system evaluates emotional expressions, and memory centers compare this new person to every significant relationship you've ever experienced.

Studies using fMRI technology show that attraction activates the same neural reward pathways as addictive substances—the ventral tegmental area releases dopamine, creating feelings of excitement and motivation to pursue connection. This isn't a metaphor; attraction literally creates a neurochemical high that can override rational judgment and create powerful cravings for proximity to the desired person.

Yet this chemical symphony plays differently for each individual. Your personal history, attachment style, and even current stress levels influence which neural pathways activate most strongly. Someone with anxious attachment might experience particularly intense dopamine responses to potential partners, while those with avoidant attachment might have more muted neurochemical reactions that feel like calm interest rather than overwhelming desire.

This initial neurochemical response explains why attraction can feel so compelling and irrational—your ancient brain systems are responding to perceived genetic and emotional compatibility signals before your conscious mind has time to evaluate whether this person actually aligns with your values, goals, or relationship needs.

The Role of Pheromones and Unconscious Signals

Beneath the level of conscious awareness, a secret conversation unfolds through chemical signals that bypass rational thought entirely. Pheromones—chemical messengers carried in breath and skin—communicate genetic information that helps determine compatibility on the most fundamental biological level.

Research has shown that people tend to be most attracted to others whose immune system genetics (specifically MHC or major histocompatibility complex genes) complement their own. This unconscious genetic assessment happens through scent detection so subtle that people don't realize they're evaluating genetic compatibility through smell alone.

Women can literally smell genetic diversity in potential partners, being most attracted to men whose immune systems differ from their own in ways that would create robust immunity in offspring. This ancient wisdom operates entirely below conscious awareness, influencing who feels mysteriously appealing versus who triggers subtle feelings of discomfort or disinterest.

Beyond pheromones, subtle visual and auditory cues communicate fertility, health, genetic quality, and emotional stability. Facial symmetry signals developmental stability and genetic fitness. Voice pitch and rhythm convey hormonal health and emotional regulation. Even the way someone moves their body communicates confidence, physical vitality, and social status in ways that influence attraction without conscious recognition.

The Psychology of Facial Features and Physical Preferences

What we find physically attractive isn't simply cultural or random—deep evolutionary patterns influence our responses to certain facial features, body proportions, and physical characteristics. These preferences exist across cultures and appear early in development, suggesting they're hardwired responses rather than learned associations.

Research reveals that both men and women are drawn to faces that signal genetic health and reproductive potential. Clear skin, facial symmetry, and features that suggest optimal hormone levels during development consistently rate as attractive across diverse cultures and time periods.

Yet individual variation in these preferences reveals how personal history shapes attraction. Someone who experienced safety and love with a parent who had particular physical characteristics might find similar features especially appealing in romantic partners. Conversely, negative associations with certain physical traits can create unconscious aversion patterns that influence attraction in ways the person doesn't consciously understand.

The interplay between universal attraction patterns and personal history explains why you might feel drawn to someone who doesn't fit conventional beauty standards while feeling unmoved by objectively attractive people. Your unconscious mind weighs evolutionary signals against personal associations, creating attraction patterns that feel mysterious but actually follow psychological logic.

How Do Our Past Experiences Shape Who We Find Attractive?

Attraction patterns are deeply influenced by early relationships, cultural programming, and significant emotional experiences that create unconscious templates for what feels familiar, safe, or exciting in romantic connections.

The Imprint of Early Relationships

Your first experiences of love, care, and emotional connection create powerful templates that influence romantic attraction throughout your life. If your earliest caregivers were warm, consistent, and emotionally available, you're likely to feel drawn to partners who embody these same qualities of stability and emotional accessibility.

Conversely, if early relationships involved inconsistency, emotional unavailability, or even trauma, these patterns can create complex attraction dynamics where familiar dysfunction feels more compelling than healthy availability. This isn't self-sabotage—it's your unconscious mind seeking what feels psychologically familiar, even when that familiarity isn't in your best interest.

Attachment research demonstrates that people often feel most attracted to partners whose emotional availability matches their early caregiving experiences. Those who experienced inconsistent care might find themselves drawn to partners who alternate between intense attention and emotional withdrawal, recreating the uncertainty that feels like home.

This early imprinting explains why attraction can feel so irrational and why people often find themselves repeatedly drawn to similar types despite conscious desires for something different. Your unconscious mind recognizes patterns from early relationships and signals attraction to people who fit those templates, regardless of whether those patterns actually serve your adult relationship goals.

Cultural and Social Programming

The landscape of attraction is painted not only by personal history but by the cultural waters in which we swim. Society's messages about desirability, beauty standards, status symbols, and relationship roles create powerful influences on who feels attractive and appealing versus who seems invisible or unsuitable.

Media representations, family expectations, and social group norms all contribute to shaping attraction preferences in ways that often operate below conscious awareness. You might find yourself drawn to certain professions, educational backgrounds, or lifestyle choices not because they genuinely align with your values, but because cultural programming has associated them with desirability and social worth.

Yet personal attraction often rebels against cultural programming in interesting ways. People frequently find themselves attracted to individuals who don't fit their stated "type" or social expectations, suggesting that deeper psychological and biological factors can override cultural influences when genuine compatibility exists.

Understanding cultural influences on attraction helps distinguish between authentic personal preferences and internalized social expectations. This awareness allows for more conscious choice about which cultural messages to embrace versus which ones might be limiting your openness to potentially compatible partners.

Trauma and Healing Patterns

Significant emotional experiences—both positive and traumatic—create lasting impressions on attraction patterns. Positive experiences with certain types of people can create lifelong preferences, while traumatic experiences can create either attraction or aversion patterns that influence romantic choices for decades.

Sometimes trauma creates attraction to people who feel familiar in problematic ways—those with similar emotional unavailability, control issues, or other characteristics that recreate familiar dynamics. Other times, trauma creates a strong aversion to anyone who resembles past harmful relationships, potentially causing people to miss out on compatible partners who happen to share superficial characteristics with past harmful individuals.

The healing journey often involves developing more conscious awareness of how past experiences influence current attraction patterns. Working with relationship professionals can help distinguish between attraction patterns that serve current relationship goals versus those that unconsciously recreate past dynamics that weren't actually fulfilling or healthy.

As healing progresses, many people notice their attraction patterns shifting toward individuals who offer genuine emotional safety, compatibility, and growth potential rather than familiar intensity or drama that temporarily activates old neural pathways but doesn't support lasting satisfaction.

Why Do We Sometimes Feel Drawn to People Who Aren't Good for Us?

The psychological factors that create intense attraction don't always align with the qualities that predict relationship satisfaction, creating situations where our hearts pull us toward people our minds know aren't compatible partners.

The Biochemistry of Intermittent Reinforcement

One of the most powerful psychological phenomena in attraction involves intermittent reinforcement—when someone provides inconsistent attention, affection, or availability. This pattern creates particularly strong neurochemical responses because uncertainty activates the brain's reward systems more intensely than predictable positive experiences.

When someone is sometimes available and sometimes distant, your brain releases larger amounts of dopamine during the moments of connection, creating an addictive cycle where the uncertainty itself becomes part of what feels exciting and attractive. This explains why consistently available, kind partners can sometimes feel "boring" compared to those who create emotional rollercoasters.

The gambling industry understands this psychology perfectly—variable reward schedules create much stronger addiction patterns than consistent rewards. Unfortunately, this same mechanism can make emotionally unavailable or inconsistent partners feel more intensely attractive than stable, secure individuals who would actually make better long-term partners.

Recognizing this pattern helps explain why you might feel more "chemistry" with someone who creates anxiety and uncertainty versus someone who offers genuine emotional safety and consistency. The intensity isn't necessarily indicating compatibility—it might be signaling a psychological trap that activates addiction-like neural pathways.

Unconscious Attempts to Heal Past Wounds

Sometimes attraction to problematic partners represents unconscious attempts to master unresolved emotional experiences from the past. If you experienced rejection, abandonment, or emotional unavailability in early relationships, part of your psyche might be drawn to similar dynamics in adult relationships as an attempt to finally "win" the love that was previously unavailable.

This unconscious drive to heal old wounds by succeeding where you previously failed can create a powerful attraction to people who embody characteristics of past relationships that caused pain. The unconscious logic suggests that if you can make this unavailable person love you, you'll finally prove your worthiness and heal the original wound.

Unfortunately, this strategy rarely works because the attraction is based on recreating past dynamics rather than building healthy new ones. The very characteristics that make someone feel familiar and attractive—emotional unavailability, inconsistency, or emotional complexity—often prevent them from providing the secure love that would actually heal past wounds.

Understanding this pattern helps distinguish between attraction based on genuine compatibility versus attraction based on unconscious attempts to resolve past relationships. True healing usually requires choosing partners who offer something genuinely different from past harmful experiences rather than opportunities to finally succeed at familiar patterns.

The Appeal of Conquest and Challenge

Human psychology includes drives for mastery, achievement, and overcoming obstacles that can unfortunately, extend into romantic attraction. Some people feel most attracted to partners who seem difficult to "win" or who present challenges that activate competitive instincts rather than collaborative partnership desires.

This conquest-oriented attraction can make emotionally available, genuinely interested partners feel too easy or insufficiently challenging to maintain interest. The pursuit becomes more exciting than the actual relationship, leading to patterns where attraction fades once someone becomes consistently available and committed.

The challenge-seeking aspect of attraction often appeals to people with certain personality traits—high achievers, competitive individuals, or those whose self-worth depends heavily on external validation through difficult accomplishments. Recognizing this pattern helps distinguish between authentic attraction to someone's character versus attraction to the challenge they represent.

Healthy relationships ultimately require moving beyond conquest dynamics toward genuine appreciation for partnership, collaboration, and mutual vulnerability. The most satisfying long-term connections often involve people who feel "easy" to love rather than constantly challenging to pursue or understand.

What Role Do Similarities and Differences Play in Attraction?

Research reveals complex patterns where certain similarities enhance attraction while specific differences create complementary appeal, suggesting that optimal compatibility involves strategic combinations of shared traits and complementary characteristics.

The Comfort of Similarity

Extensive research on assortative mating demonstrates that people tend to be most attracted to others who share fundamental characteristics—similar intelligence levels, educational backgrounds, values, and life goals. This preference for similarity appears across cultures and time periods, suggesting deep psychological drives toward familiarity and predictability in long-term partnerships.

Similarity creates psychological comfort because shared perspectives, experiences, and values reduce the cognitive effort required for mutual understanding. When someone shares your background, sense of humor, intellectual interests, or core values, interactions feel effortless and natural, creating positive associations that enhance attraction over time.

Physical similarity also influences attraction in subtle ways. Research shows that couples tend to be matched on physical attractiveness levels, and people often find faces that resemble their own family members moderately attractive—not enough to trigger incest avoidance mechanisms, but enough to create unconscious familiarity and appeal.

Yet excessive similarity can sometimes reduce attraction by creating feelings of predictability or lack of growth potential. The most sustainable attraction often involves enough similarity to ensure compatibility with sufficient difference to maintain interest and personal development opportunities.

The Intrigue of Complementary Differences

While similarity provides comfort and compatibility, certain types of differences create powerful attraction through complementary dynamics that enhance both partners' lives. These differences work best when they represent strengths in areas where your partner has growth opportunities, creating mutual enhancement rather than fundamental incompatibility.

Personality differences can create attractive complementary dynamics—an extrovert might be drawn to an introvert's depth and thoughtfulness, while the introvert appreciates the extrovert's social energy and emotional expressiveness. These differences enhance both partners when they respect and learn from each other's natural strengths.

Skill-based differences also create appealing complementary attractions. Someone who excels at emotional intelligence might be drawn to a partner's analytical abilities, while the analytical person appreciates their partner's interpersonal skills. These complementary strengths create partnerships where both people feel enhanced by what their partner brings to the relationship.

The key to healthy complementary attraction lies in mutual respect and appreciation for differences rather than attempts to change or fix each other. When differences are viewed as enhancement opportunities rather than problems to solve, they can create lasting attraction and growth within the relationship.

When Opposites Attract vs. When They Clash

The popular saying "opposites attract" contains both truth and oversimplification. Certain types of opposites do create powerful attraction, while others create ongoing conflict that erodes relationship satisfaction over time. Understanding which differences enhance relationships versus which ones create problems helps evaluate attraction patterns more wisely.

Complementary opposites that work well include different but compatible personality styles, varying but respected approaches to problem-solving, and different strengths that enhance the partnership. An organized person might appreciate a spontaneous partner's creativity, while the spontaneous person values their partner's stability and planning abilities.

Problematic opposites typically involve fundamental differences in values, life goals, or relationship expectations that require one person to compromise their authentic needs consistently. Different approaches to finances, family priorities, communication styles, or personal growth can create ongoing tension when they reflect incompatible core values rather than complementary preferences.

The difference between attractive opposites and problematic ones often lies in whether the differences enhance both partners' lives or require ongoing negotiation and compromise of essential needs. Healthy attraction to differences involves appreciation and learning, while problematic attraction to opposites often involves attempts to change or fix fundamental characteristics.

How Can Understanding Attraction Psychology Improve Your Dating Life?

Conscious awareness of your attraction patterns empowers you to make more intentional choices about romantic connections, distinguishing between chemistry that signals genuine compatibility versus patterns that recreate familiar but ultimately unsatisfying dynamics.

Developing Attraction Awareness

The first step in using attraction psychology beneficially involves developing awareness of your personal patterns without judgment. Notice who you tend to find attractive and what specific qualities draw your attention. Pay attention to whether your attraction patterns tend to lead to satisfying relationships or repeated disappointments.

Consider keeping a dating journal that tracks not just who you're attracted to, but how those attractions develop over time. Do you find initial chemistry tends to grow or fade as you get to know someone better? Are you more attracted to people who seem challenging versus those who seem genuinely available and interested?

Notice the relationship between your conscious preferences and your actual attraction patterns. You might say you want someone kind and emotionally available, but find yourself most excited about people who are complex and emotionally unpredictable. This awareness helps identify areas where conscious and unconscious patterns might be in conflict.

Understanding your patterns without self-criticism creates space for conscious choice about which attraction signals to follow versus which ones might be leading you away from your actual relationship goals and needs.

Distinguishing Chemistry from Compatibility

One of the most valuable skills for improving your dating life involves learning to distinguish between intense chemistry and genuine compatibility. Chemistry often involves neurochemical activation that can occur for many reasons—some healthy and some based on psychological patterns that don't predict relationship satisfaction.

Taking our Relationship Readiness Test can help you understand what you actually need for lasting relationship satisfaction versus what creates temporary excitement or attraction. This awareness helps evaluate whether strong chemistry with someone reflects genuine potential or familiar patterns that historically haven't led to fulfilling partnerships.

Compatibility involves shared values, complementary life goals, mutual respect, and the ability to navigate challenges together constructively. These qualities might not create immediate fireworks but tend to predict long-term satisfaction and growth much more accurately than intense initial chemistry alone.

Learning to appreciate the quieter satisfactions of genuine compatibility—feeling understood, experiencing consistent kindness, enjoying easy communication—can help you recognize relationship potential that might not announce itself through dramatic chemistry but offers much deeper fulfillment over time.

Expanding Your Attraction Patterns Consciously

If you notice your attraction patterns consistently lead to relationships that don't satisfy your deeper needs, it's possible to consciously expand your openness to different types of people while respecting your authentic preferences and needs.

This doesn't mean forcing yourself to date people you don't find attractive, but rather becoming curious about people who might not fit your usual type but demonstrate qualities that align with your relationship goals. Sometimes genuine compatibility creates its own form of attraction that grows over time as emotional intimacy develops.

Spend time with couples who demonstrate healthy relationships to observe what a successful partnership actually looks like in daily life. This can help calibrate your attraction and appreciation toward qualities that support long-term satisfaction rather than just short-term excitement.

Consider whether your current attraction patterns serve your conscious relationship goals or whether they might be based on psychological patterns that worked in past circumstances but don't support your current life and growth aspirations.

Using Attraction as Information Rather Than Direction

Perhaps the most sophisticated approach to attraction psychology involves using your attraction responses as valuable information while maintaining conscious choice about how to respond to that information. Attraction tells you something important about your psychology, past experiences, and unconscious patterns, but it doesn't have to determine your relationship choices.

Strong attraction might signal genuine compatibility, or it might indicate psychological patterns worth exploring in therapy. Lack of immediate attraction might suggest incompatibility, or it might reflect unfamiliarity with healthy relationship dynamics that could develop over time.

Using attraction as information means paying attention to what draws you to people while also evaluating whether acting on that attraction serves your conscious relationship goals. This approach honors both your emotional responses and your rational assessment of what actually creates lasting satisfaction.

This more nuanced relationship with attraction often develops through experience, self-reflection, and sometimes professional support to understand patterns that might not be immediately obvious or that involve complex psychological dynamics worth exploring more deeply.

The psychology of attraction reveals that the invisible force drawing you to certain people is neither random magic nor simple biology—it's an intricate dance between evolutionary patterns, personal history, and the unique architecture of your individual psyche. Understanding these forces doesn't diminish the wonder of connection; it enhances your ability to choose connections that serve both your heart's desires and your mind's wisdom.

When you understand why you feel drawn to certain people, you gain the power to evaluate whether those attractions lead toward the kind of relationships you actually want to build. Some attractions signal deep compatibility and growth potential, while others reflect psychological patterns that once protected you but might no longer serve your current relationship goals.

The most fulfilling romantic connections often combine the magic of genuine attraction with the satisfaction of authentic compatibility—relationships where chemistry grows stronger over time because it's built on mutual understanding, shared values, and the joy of discovering someone who sees and appreciates your authentic self. This is the kind of attraction worth following, wherever it might lead.

Ready to understand your unique attraction patterns and relationship needs? Take our Relationship Readiness Test to discover insights that will help you recognize attraction that serves your deepest desires for meaningful connection.

Wayne Fraser

Wayne is a serial entrepreneur with over 25 years in Business Consulting, Entrepreneurship, Governance Operations and technology.

Get Your

Take our quick survey and get your personalized Relationship Score!