Red Flags vs. Green Flags: What to Watch for on a First Date

You sit across the table. There’s candlelight, a drink in hand, maybe a slight flutter in your chest. You smile. They smile. And in the back of your head, a small committee is already at work.

“They’re funny. That’s a green flag, right?”
“Wait, did they just interrupt again?”
“Hmm... maybe they’re just nervous?”

Sound familiar?

First dates are equal parts chemistry and chaos. You’re trying to feel a connection while also assessing the person in front of you, without making it feel like a job interview. And the truth is, some of the most important clues about someone’s emotional health show up early... but quietly.

That’s where red flags and green flags come in.

They’re not warnings or wins. They’re simply signals. Early data points. Glimpses into how someone navigates vulnerability, communication, boundaries, and respect.

But here’s the twist: noticing these signals isn’t just about them—it’s about you, too. How you interpret them depends on what you're emotionally ready to see.

So before you start flag-spotting, it helps to check in with yourself. Are you tuned in to your needs, or just eager to make it work? A quick relationship readiness test might help you figure that out—so you’re not seeing what you want to see, but what’s really there.

Let’s unpack the flags—red, green, and everything in between.

Understanding Red Flags: Subtle Warnings Most People Miss

Let’s get one thing straight—red flags aren’t always neon signs flashing “RUN.” Most of the time, they’re quiet. They blend in. They even wear charm like a disguise.

That’s what makes them so easy to miss.

Especially on a first date, when everyone’s a little nervous, a little polished, a little “best version of themselves.” But underneath all that? There are behaviors worth noticing.

So, what is a red flag?

A red flag is a behavior or attitude that signals potential emotional harm or misalignment in the long run. It doesn’t mean the person is “bad.” It means there’s something off, something that might become a bigger issue over time.

And here’s the thing: most of us aren’t blind to red flags. We see them. We just explain them away.
We say things like:

• “They didn’t really mean it like that.”
• “They’ve just been through a lot.”
• “It’s too soon to judge.”
  
  

What’s really going on? Sometimes we’re not ready to walk away. Sometimes our past teaches us that discomfort is normal. Sometimes we’re just tired of being alone.

A few red flags that show up early (but rarely get called out):

• Inconsistent communication: Hot one moment, cold the next.
• Subtle boundary-pushing: Like teasing you about your preferences or nudging you past your comfort zone.
• Talking poorly about exes: If every ex was “crazy,” that’s not a story—it’s a pattern.
• Love bombing: Over-the-top compliments, big declarations, or early intensity that doesn’t match the timeline.
• Disrespect in small ways: Rudeness to service staff. Dismissing your opinion. Laughing at your vulnerability.
  
  

You don’t need to analyze these things with a microscope—but you do need to trust yourself enough to notice them.

And if you’re wondering why some red flags feel strangely familiar—or even a little magnetic—that’s worth exploring. Our2Souls offers a set of powerful assessments designed to help you understand your own emotional patterns, triggers, and blind spots.

Sometimes, the red flag isn’t the person across from you.
It’s what you’re tolerating because you haven’t looked inward yet.

Green Flags: What Healthy Connection Actually Looks Like

Let’s be honest, red flags get all the buzz. We share them in group chats, screenshot them for friends, build entire TikToks around them. But what about green flags?

What about the moments that don’t raise alarms but quietly whisper:
“This feels... good.”

Green flags don’t always stand out. In fact, they’re often subtle. But they’re the real clues that someone might have the emotional capacity, self-awareness, and relational skills to meet you in a meaningful way.

And spotting green flags isn’t about putting someone on a pedestal. It’s about recognizing emotional health in action.

Real Green Flags Look Like This:

• They respect your boundaries—without asking twice.
• They listen without waiting to talk.
• They’re honest without oversharing.
• They’re comfortable with quiet moments.
• They don’t rush the connection.
  
  

And here’s something important: green flags often show up as emotional pacing. That quiet, respectful rhythm where no one’s pushing, proving, or performing.

If you’re wondering how to nurture those green flags into something real, it starts with how you both build from the beginning. This guide on how to build emotional intimacy early in a relationship is full of practical steps that keep you grounded—while letting connection grow.

Because green flags don’t guarantee someone is “the one.”
But they do tell you someone might be ready.

Gray Flags: When You're Just Not Sure Yet

Not every behavior fits neatly into a box. Not everything on a first date is a red flag or a green one.

Some things? They're just... gray.

Maybe they’re nervous. Maybe you are. Maybe it’s just one weird comment that hangs in the air for too long, or a moment that feels off but not quite wrong.

Gray flags are the things that make you pause—but not necessarily run. They're often confusing because they live in context. They need time, not assumptions.

What do gray flags look like?

• They interrupt you a few times—but apologize and adjust.
• They seem guarded or quiet.
• They mention past baggage—but don’t dwell there.
• They joke in ways that feel… slightly off.
  
  

Gray flags ask you to zoom out.
Observe patterns. Not just moments.

First dates are snapshots. Not full stories.
Give the story a few pages before deciding if it’s worth finishing.

Your Own Reactions Are Flags Too: What Your Nervous System Is Telling You

We spend so much time analyzing the other person—what they said, how they acted, whether they checked the right boxes—that we forget to check in with the one person who’s actually been there the whole time:

You.

Your body knows.
It keeps the score.
It collects the vibe before your brain has time to rationalize it.

Things to notice during (and after) the date:

• Do you feel calm—or like you’re auditioning?
• Do you feel energized—or a little drained?
• Did you feel safe saying “no” or “I’m not sure”?
• Was your body relaxed or tense most of the time?
  
  

Your nervous system isn’t dramatic—it’s direct.
It tells you things long before logic kicks in.

To understand how emotional safety often begins with empathy, explore this guide on empathy and emotional intimacy. The more you learn to recognize that calm feeling, the easier it becomes to trust it.

What to Do When You Notice a Flag (Any Color)

You’ve had the date. You noticed something.

Now what?

When You Notice a Red Flag

• Is it a one-off or a pattern?
• Can they take accountability?
• Do you feel safe being honest?
  
  

If the red flag feels like a preview of future chaos, walk away.

When You Notice a Green Flag

• Don’t over-romanticize it.
• Stay curious.
• Let it be a good sign—not a guarantee.
  
  

When You Notice a Gray Flag

• Don’t ignore it, but don’t overreact.
• Let time reveal clarity.
• Be honest with yourself about what feels off.
  
  

Need help sorting through your thoughts? Try using the Our2Souls app to reflect privately and track patterns over time.

Because noticing a flag doesn’t require immediate action.
It requires self-trust.

Bringing It Together: Slow Dating Is Smart Dating

The best thing you can bring to a first date isn’t a killer outfit, the perfect story, or even an impressive answer to “What are you looking for?”

It’s awareness.

Because red flags, green flags, gray areas—they’re not tests to pass or fail. They’re just information. Signals. Insights.

Slow dating isn’t about wasting time. It’s about honoring it.

So before your next first date, do something that most people skip: check in with yourself. A quick relationship readiness test can help you tune into what you’re truly ready for—so you don’t confuse pressure with potential, or fantasy with truth.

The goal isn’t to find perfect.
The goal is to find real.

And that starts with knowing what you’re looking at—and what you’re feeling—in the first place.

‍